There’s no shortage of gloomy prognostication about the impact on Indian society as the rupee falls into global disfavor, with a value (in U.S. dollars) barely half its high point in 2008. I have a different perspective: There is a silver lining in this dismal cloud. The situation could even be positive for those who are building businesses to meet the most fundamental needs of India’s poor, and for those investing in such businesses. As co-founder and managing partner of Unitus Seed Fund, my team and I look at dozens of business proposals every month from entrepreneurs who create opportunities for consumers at the “base of the economic pyramid,” or “BoP” to obtain economic self-reliance, education, and basic necessities. These new businesses depend largely on capital that flows into venture and private equity funds to fuel their growth. With the Indian rupee’s rapid depreciation and the likely economic slowdown, will impact investing capital from domestic and overseas sources continue to flow, or will it slow? For a number of reasons, I expect funds to increase, which means that more “impact businesses” will be created and scaled up. The result could be more quality goods, services, and opportunities for India’s poor. First, impact funds will flow because consumers will keep consuming. Yes, the increasing cost of oil and certain food staples will hit the one billion poor living on family income of less than $10 a day. The Indian government subsidizes many energy products to deflect the full impact on the BoP. These subsidies are likely to diminish due to budgetary pressures, but not disappear anytime soon. India largely feeds itself for core food staples, so the domestic food market is only indirectly affected by the rupee’s fall, again through the price of oil as an input to agriculture. India’s government — controversially — has just expanded its food subsidies for up to three-quarters of Indians, blunting most food price changes. Some poor consumers will undoubtedly see a decrease in income. But given that the kind of impact startups that investors target supply the most cost-effective basic necessities, education, healthcare, and skills training to consumers, I think these companies will continue to thrive. The purchasing priorities of these consumers will not change with respect to the most fundamental unmet needs of the poor. So domestic funds flowing to impact opportunities should continue on their current growth trajectory, and international impact investors will be getting more company for their dollar, resulting in a net-positive outlook for impact opportunities. Second, starting companies in challenging economic times is a good strategy. Investors like investing in innovative, market-disrupting companies when the economy is weak. A company that can be successful serving low-income consumers in a challenging economic environment will truly shine when the economy turns around and growth rates increase. In weaker economic conditions, companies are forced to maintain even tighter cost controls, and they’ll have generally lower costs of inputs, including labor. Investors prefer challenging economic times vs. over-heated market, as anyone can attest who invested in US tech venture funds just before the “dot bomb” or in real estate just before 2008. Summing it up: 70 or more rupees to the US dollar will cause plenty of pain for businesses that export to India. And it may cause a little pain for low-income consumers due to the increase in oil and oil-linked commodity prices. But for local and global investors making a bet on the growing number of impact startups serving domestic market needs for education, basic necessities, and healthcare, a 70-rupee dollar is a fine thing, producing better impact startups and giving investors more company for their money. And for hundreds of thousands of small businesses in artisanal craft or export-linked activities, the devalued rupee brings immediate opportunities for growth. They should be able to look forward to increased support from local and global impact investors seeking to increase both the profits and social impact of their dollars.
September 4, 2013 | Frontier and Growth Markets
Fall of the Rupee is Not so Bad for India’s Poor — and Just Fine for Impact Investors
The team at
ImpactAlpha
Stay up to date with what matters to you...
Choose beats that you're interested in, and we'll show you more of them as you explore...
{{beat.name}}Catalytic Capital
Catalytic Capital | March 15, 2023
Caisse Régionale de Refinancement Hypothécaire raises $274 million for affordable housing in West Africa
ImpactAlpha, March 15 – Caisse Régionale de Refinancement Hypothécaire in Togo raised $274 million via a long-term bond issuance to invest in affordable …
Sustaining Impact | March 9, 2023
Leveraging catalytic capital to transform economic systems in Africa
Editor’s note: This blog is part of ImpactAlpha’s series, “Sustaining Impact,” authored by participants in the Catalytic Capital Consortium (C3) Sustaining Learning Labs. Key insights …
Catalytic Capital | February 22, 2023
Opportunity International raises $101 million to catalyze loans to boost livelihoods in low-income countries
ImpactAlpha, February 22 — Chicago-based nonprofit lender Opportunity International has raised $101 million in philanthropic capital from backers including the Bill & Melinda …
Sustaining Impact | February 15, 2023
Beyond the fairy tale: Investment strategies that catalyze real impact
Editor’s note: This blog is part of ImpactAlpha’s series, “Sustaining Impact,” authored by participants in the Catalytic Capital Consortium (C3) Sustaining Learning Labs. Key insights …
Catalytic Capital | February 2, 2023
Four principles to help catalytic investors optimize allocations and scale impact
Editor’s note: This blog is part of ImpactAlpha’s “Scaling Impact” series, authored by participants in the Catalytic Capital Consortium (C3) Scaling Learning Labs. Key insights …
Catalytic Capital | January 27, 2023
Why development finance institutions are being pressed to ‘publish what you fund’
Development finance institutions are essential to the mobilization of capital to slow climate change and to meet the Sustainable Development Goals. So why …
Catalytic Capital | January 26, 2023
Invest Appalachia secures $19 million to bridge investment gaps in Appalachia
ImpactAlpha, January 26 — Central Appalachia’s forests and ecosystems are some of the most biodiverse in the world, and its mountains among the …
Impact Management | January 25, 2023
To catalyze climate capital, development finance institutions are pressed to ‘publish what you fund’
ImpactAlpha, January 25 – Six trillion dollars. That’s roughly how much is needed annually to fight climate change and meet the U.N.’s Sustainable …
Scaling Impact | January 23, 2023
How to get more international money flowing in local currency
Editor’s note: This blog is part of ImpactAlpha’s “Scaling Impact” series, authored by participants in the Catalytic Capital Consortium (C3) Scaling Learning Labs. Key insights …
Climate Finance | January 23, 2023
Variations on a theme: Securitizing fees and taxes to finance climate adaptation
Ghana securitized an education tax to improve access to education and a petrol tax to pay off legacy debts in the banking sector. …
Scaling Impact | January 12, 2023
Indispensable growth factor for impact funds, strategies and fund managers: catalytic capital
Editor’s note: This blog is part of ImpactAlpha’s “Scaling Impact” series, authored by participants in the Catalytic Capital Consortium (C3) Scaling Learning Labs. Key insights …
Climate Finance | January 10, 2023
Matching local projects with climate capital to deploy community infrastructure
ImpactAlpha, Jan. 10 – The Great Deployment is on. The capital is teed up. The technology is ready. The Inflation Reduction Act and …
Muni Impact
Water | March 23, 2023
Putting a ‘price on water’ and other opportunities to address the H2O crisis
ImpactAlpha, Mar. 23 – In financial markets, water is becoming the new carbon. From early stage startups and corporate supply chains to public policy …
Muni Impact | March 1, 2023
The winding road to ESG standards in the municipal bond market
ImpactAlpha, Feb. 29 – In October 2021, a paper manufacturer in Kalamazoo, Michigan, issued $100 million of what it called “green bonds” through …
Muni Impact | February 9, 2023
Engaging racial-equity risks and opportunities in municipal finance (video)
ImpactAlpha, Feb. 9 – The fatal beating by police of Tyre Nichols in Memphis last month exposed risks to the city’s finances that have …
Muni Impact | February 9, 2023
Munis 101: Players, capital flows and mechanics in the $4 trillion municipal-bond market
ImpactAlpha, Feb. 9 – Municipal bonds have been called the original impact investments, the source of much needed capital for highways, bridges, schools and …
Impact Management | February 6, 2023
Accounting for impact at Candide, MicroVest, Echoing Green and other investment managers
ImpactAlpha, Feb. 6. 2023 – The age of ad hoc impact reporting may be coming to an end. In the meantime, we’ve taken a …
Podcasts | February 3, 2023
Finding the opportunities in (and the problems with) the municipal bond market
ImpactAlpha’s David Bank joins Host Monique Aiken to to share some takeaways from this week’s Agents of Impact Call on the steps that …
Muni Impact | January 31, 2023
Activest’s FIRE strategy seeks to bend the arc of municipal finance toward ‘fiscal justice’
ImpactAlpha, Jan. 31 – It’s distressingly easy to find places where city finances are distorted by systemic racism or outright bigotry. It’s harder …
Muni Impact | January 24, 2023
‘You can’t do impact on a passive basis’: Q&A with activist muni-investor Eric Glass
ImpactAlpha, Jan. 24 – After 15 years as an analyst, trader, and portfolio manager at AllianceBernstein, Eric Glass was asked in 2015 to develop …
Muni Impact | January 24, 2023
Market hypocrisy, political opportunism, and the common good
The attorney general of Texas earlier this month accused Citigroup of running afoul of a state law that “bars most government contracts with …
Muni Impact | January 17, 2023
Overheard at the Public Finance Conference: Investment opportunities in Emerging Market America
ImpactAlpha, Jan. 17 – A computer glitch that snarled air traffic last week presented a fitting backdrop as government and finance leaders gathered …
Muni Impact | January 12, 2023
The billion-dollar cost to the ESG culture wars
ImpactAlpha, Jan. 12 – Banks that use environmental, social, or governance, or ESG frameworks in their investing practice are being targeted by state legislators …
Climate Finance | January 10, 2023
Matching local projects with climate capital to deploy community infrastructure
ImpactAlpha, Jan. 10 – The Great Deployment is on. The capital is teed up. The technology is ready. The Inflation Reduction Act and …
Impact Careers
Impact Careers | March 24, 2023
The Week’s Impact Jobs: March 24, 2023
ImpactAlpha, March 24 — Impact investors are looking to add new talent across all continents, from senior associates and investment officers in India and Tanzania …
Impact Careers | March 17, 2023
The Week’s Impact Jobs: March 17, 2023
ImpactAlpha, March 17 — Employers in the fast-growing global impact investing market are hunting for talents. From impact associates and analysts to impact …
Impact Careers | March 3, 2023
The Week’s Impact Jobs: March 3, 2023
ImpactAlpha, March 4 — From interns and associates to executive directors and board members, impact firms are on the hunt for your talent. Just …
Impact Careers | February 24, 2023
The Week’s Impact Jobs: February 24, 2023
ImpactAlpha, February 24 — Opportunities in impact investing are global. Need proof? Check out this week’s roundup of impact jobs. Global locations i2i …
The Brief | February 17, 2023
The Week’s Impact Jobs: February 17, 2023
ImpactAlpha, February 17 — The U.S. economy added roughly 517,000 new jobs last month, dropping the unemployment rate to a record low 3.4% …
Impact Voices | October 11, 2021
10 tips to speed your transition to an impact finance career
There is no denying that impact finance is one of the most sought after spaces in finance right now, but what does it …
Agents of Impact | September 20, 2018
How to get a job in impact investing
ImpactAlpha, September 20th (original post date 2/6/18 on Medium.com by Lauren Cochran). I get 4–5 requests to do an informational interview/coffee chat/career session per …